Murder on Cold Street

July 27, 2020
A locked-room mystery drives Thomas’s entertaining if implausible fifth Lady Sherlock whodunit (after 2019’s The Art of Theft). When Scotland Yard’s Insp. Robert Treadles becomes the suspect in a double murder, his wife, Alice Treadles, consults detective Charlotte Holmes, Robert’s sometime collaborator who claims to be acting on behalf of her ill, bedridden brother no one ever sees, Sherlock Holmes. Two London bobbies on patrol found Robert in a locked bedroom in an unoccupied house, brandishing his service revolver. The bedroom’s other occupants, John Longstead, who lived next door, and his nephew, Ambrose Sullivan, were shot to death. Both victims worked at Cousins Manufacturing, a company that Mrs. Treadles recently took over. Despite the incriminating circumstances, the inspector’s wife believes in his innocence, and Charlotte agrees to investigate, ostensibly in accord with the instructions of her “brother.” Developments in Charlotte’s love life complement the sleuthing. This may appeal more to fans of lighter Victorian mysteries than to Sherlockians. Agent: Kristin Nelson, Nelson Literary.

September 1, 2020
Award-winning historical-mystery author Thomas presents another engaging entry in her Lady Sherlock series, with the unusual premise of intrepid detective Sherlock Holmes and his loyal sidekick, Watson, reimagined as women. In her latest outing, Charlotte Holmes faces what may her most challenging and baffling case yet. Police Inspector Robert Treadles has been charged with murder, and his wife begs Charlotte to help prove Treadles' innocence. Although the evidence against Treadles appears indisputable, Charlotte agrees to take it on, using both her excellent deductive skills and the additional resources of her network of loyal female colleagues. She eventually cracks the case, while still finding time to resurrect her budding romance with Lord Ingram Ashburton and avoid the long arm of her deadly enemy, Moriarty. While the case itself is intriguing, it is the portrayal of the societal expectations and restrictions faced by women in Victorian times, along with Charlotte's ingenuity in surmounting these obstacles, that makes this such a winning read.(Reprinted with permission of Booklist, copyright 2020, American Library Association.)

October 2, 2020

It is almost Christmas and Charlotte Holmes, Lady Sherlock, is decked out for the holiday season in her own original way. However, the celebrations are put on hold when Inspector Treadles is discovered in a locked room with two murdered men, both of whom had ties to Cousin's Manufacturing, which Mrs. Treadles recently inherited from her father. To make matters worse, the inspector has refused to shed any light on how he came to be in such a precarious position. Instead, he and Mrs. Treadles implore Charlotte to seek advice from Sherlock Holmes. This fifth "Lady Sherlock" installment (after The Art of Theft) addresses the challenges women faced in the Victorian era if they planned to have a career. As Mrs. Treadles works to establish her authority at Cousin's Manufacturing, Charlotte tries to untangle a puzzling and complex murder investigation. Along for the ride is Lord Ingram, who has finally come to a decision concerning his feelings for Charlotte. The brilliant characterizations complement this smart and clever murder mystery that will keep readers guessing to the very end. VERDICT This magnificent locked-room case is a dazzling holiday gift for fans of the series.--Julie Whiteley, Stephenville, TX

Copyright 2020 Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.

Starred review from July 1, 2020
Alongside brief pauses for cake, kisses, and intimate confessions, Charlotte Holmes uses her considerable mind to solve two murders and save an innocent man. Having barely recovered from a heist in France, told in The Art of Theft (2019), private detective Charlotte Holmes is asked to assist Inspector Treadles, an acquaintance from Scotland Yard who has been arrested for killing two men. His wife, Alice, is terrified for his life but hiding something, he himself is keeping mum, and the evidence looks damning. As the clock ticks, Holmes must swiftly track the preceding events, assisted by her old friend and recent lover Lord Ingram; her companion, Mrs. Watson; and Mrs. Watson's niece. The novel is sure-footed, its puzzle the most tightly structured and enjoyable of the whodunits in Thomas' series about the gender-swapped sleuth. As the group questions witnesses and ferrets out motives of potential suspects, the narrative changes rapidly from scene to scene around wintry London and from memory to memory. The telling shifts of speakers' bodies punctuate conversations, distilling emotions and speech into physicality. The novel also amplifies the series' theme of the assaults and challenges women face in a world that disadvantages them personally and professionally. More notably, it foregrounds the actions of numerous women to do so. Each is richly drawn, with her own way of resisting societal limitations regarding sex, ethnicity, and class. Holmes herself is as adept at crime-solving as ever, but when it comes to erotic love, she is still considering the ramifications of getting what she has desired for years. With an increasingly beloved detective crew, this Victorian mystery offers thrills and sharp insights into human behavior.

COPYRIGHT(2020) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.