It's All or Nothing, Vale

November 4, 2024
Before enduring a serious leg injury, Puerto Rican seventh grader Valentina “Vale” Mari Camacho was a top-ranked fencer. Now she deals with chronic pain that keeps her from competing as well as she’d like, which often leaves her frustrated, as previous pressure from her parents (Mami “used to tell me second place was the same as last”) resulted in her conflating her self-worth with her fencing skills. Vale’s older brother Manu tries to distract her by introducing her to hobbies such as art and video games, but nothing satisfies her the way fencing used to. Pushing herself to get
better, Vale attends practice but feels threatened when Cuban American teammate Myrka proves a more formidable opponent than before. As she grapples with jealousy over Myrka’s improved abilities, Vale also contends with budding attraction for her teammate. Fluid verse by Arango (Something Like Home) aptly conveys all the tension, frustration, and confusion plaguing Vale. Despite the support of well-meaning adults, it’s Vale’s peer group that most effectively facilitates her satisfying emotional arc in a narrative that highlights chosen family and the integral part it plays in forming one’s sense of self. Ages 10–14. Agent: Rebecca Eskildsen, Writers House.